Diaspora Musings

Since D Park over at Next GenerAsian Church posted his comments about being diaspora people, it provoked my own thoughts, albeit ones that are much less formed than his own.

He raises the significant question of identity formation within the context of being a diaspora people, and my own comments there reference the Jewish experience of Babylon.

The idea of how our identity, culture and faith intersect is an important one for Christians to grapple with, and I believe that the Jewish people can be our teachers in this regard, particularly the OT narratives about them.  They are essentially defined by 2 events: the Exodus from Egypt when the covenant with God was fully initiated, and the exile in Babylon, which came as a consequence of the breaking of that covenant.

What is interesting to me in the second instance is the way in which they are instructed by their religious leaders (in this case the prophet Jeremiah) to make themselves fully at home in their new land, and to seek the welfare of that place.  At the same time, we read about the so-called Hebrew boys Hannaniah, Azariah, Mishael, and Daniel who resist full assimilation into the Babylonian identity while stil managing to rise high in the bureaucracy of the Babylonian Empire.

What is interesting to me, and instructive I think for us today,  is their determination to both fully engage the culture and adapt to it (after all, Daniel is the only one who is generally known by his Hebrew name), yet at the same time retain a distinct or perhaps even more refined sense of their identity as Hebrews.  Now while the parallels to the immigrant experience is not the same (after all they were resisting the temptation to worship a false god) it is perhaps not as dissimilar as it may at first appear.

They manage to come to a genuine engagement with the society and culture of Babylon so much so that Esther rises to the position of queen in the Persian Empire (a successor to Babylon) and Nehemiah becomes the chief steward of Persia.  Daniel ans his compatriots all rise to positions of prominence within Babylon, learn the Babylonian language and customs, but none of them become “sell outs.”

In some ways Daniel and his peers might be more like first generation immigrants who are uprooted and come to the US.  It makes sense that they would somehow cling to their “home” culture.  It is significant though that they chose this option in a Babylonian society that was highly assimilationist, unlike the Persians who followed them.

What do we make of Nehemiah though?  He most certainly second (or third or fourth) generation, and probably was more fluent in Persian than Hebrew.  Yet he thinks of himself very firmly as a Jew, albeit a very persian-ized one.  When the book bearing his name opens, there is no sense that he is discontent with his identity as a persian-ized Jew, and indeed when he makes the decision to go to Jerusalem, he makes clear plans to return to Susa when he’s done.

Of course as I mentioned the parallel is not perfect, but I cannot help but wonder if part of the witness of their provided by these folks is in their refusal to give up their ethnic/cultural identity and what can be learned from that.  Or put more simply, if immigrants to the US adopt wholesale American Christianity (and more broadly American culture) is the witness to Jesus that could be provided somehow diminished.  After all, if Black people in the US had adopted White Christianity, there would have been no counter to the prevailing winds of White supremacy that blew unhindered through much of the White church and society; there would have been no civil rights movement at all.

So if my Asian (and other) Christian brothers and sisters merely assimilate and ape American Christianity, is their possible prophetic role diminished? It is probably not for me to ask, but I will dare to be cheeky and raise the question of what prophetic insight is being lost to the church when Asian Christians abandon their culture in an effort to assimilate to American norms?

Author: elderj

I was born the fourth child and third son of godly parents in Nashville Tennessee. After leaving home for college I got involved with InterVarsity, then graduated with a degree in finance. After that I got a masters in history. Nowadays I spend too much time reading, writing, thinking, and occasionally doing my job.

4 thoughts on “Diaspora Musings”

  1. It is very difficult to say where Westernization begins and ends, especially in regards to Christianity’s impact on Asia. In many cases, Westernization did not outrightly impose itself in movements characteristic of the European “will-to-power”. Thus, I believe that the notions of colonization and imperialism have a different character in the Asian mindset. Rather what is increasingly becoming more prevalent is a respect for indigenous Asian cultures and religions.

    Therefore, what AAs do not understand in my opinion, is the ramifications of their Christian beliefs. Ultimately, the Asian and AA allegiance to this Jewish Messiah can subvert the notion that Christianity can be limited to a Western religion. It is an incredibly powerful statement about the transformative and regenerative power of the gospel. But only if we choose to articulate the influence of that gospel in the deep recesses of our culture. We must prove to the world that Christianity was not merely a product of Westernization, and secondly, that we would be willing to evaluate and re-define ourselves based on the works of Christ, in essence to build a third culture that is neither Asian, Western, but Christian.

    Until AA theologians and practicitioners can begin to stem the tide by articulating what redemptive purposes our culture can share with the greater community of believers, then you are absolutely right in saying that we could very well lose our prophetic voice. I am for the fact this is not a cultural contextualization of the gospel, but that this is the Gospel contextualizion of the culture.

    Stop me if I start making any sense after a big lunch and 3 cans of soda.

  2. preach it brother! I would add that your idea of “Gospel contextualization of the culture” has inherent in it the notion that to be a Christian is to be MORE Asian (or in my case African) than less because the fullness of our humanity including our heritage, ethnicity and culture can only be realized in Christ.

    I wonder if anyone ever did any thinking about the relationship or responsibility between elder and younger in Korean culture as a metaphor for Christ’s relationship with us? Jesus as the “hyung” par-excellence who so completely brings honor to his father, sets an example for his dongsaengs, and provides the meal of grace at his own expense.

  3. saw you at dpark’s site; MORE Asian sounds so biblical! you know some korean words? do you or did you minister at a korean church?

    some good biblical diaspora examples; i don’t think asians can lose all of their culture, try as they might, even if the caucasian brothers fully receive us as “real” americans.

  4. With respect to religious beliefs-it must be recognized that participating a religion of Western origin already befalls upon Asians the loss of some Asian culture. Thus, while it’s totally valid what David had to say about how the civil rights movement being formed through “Black Christianity”, we have to admit that Christianity is not Asian, it was imposed upon some of our peoples and internalized as another belief system that Asians were willing to engage in.

    We can maintain unique Asian or AA versions of this religion, but at the same time, we must question assimilation and the fears of it. I don’t advocate so much for dropping everything at the doorstep, but also understand that it’s inevitable, especially in the AA community. Just by existing in America (or anywhere really), you are going to “lose” something of the culture you thought you were. It’s just simply survival. It’s funny, however, though, how people wind up clinging more to their roots in the context of being isolated from them, rather than when immersed in them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: